INF 530 Digital Essay: Transliteracy – essential for living and learning in the 21st Century.
Monday, June 1, 2015
Friday, March 20, 2015
Concepts and Practices in a Digital Age
![]() |
| creative commons licensed (BY-NC-SA) flickr photo by Stuck in Customs: http://flickr.com/photos/stuckincustoms/6495437857 |
As I begin to explore concepts and practices in a digital age, I find myself jumping all over the place - it is such a broad area to study. What concepts do I associate with the digital age? The first to come to mind include connectedness, collaboration, cooperation, globalisation, stability, change, belonging, sustainability, space, environment, ethics, ownership. No doubt, there are many more.
My thoughts about practices in a digital age are somewhat cloudy as I consider what practices are specific to a digital age. How are they different from those of a time before the impact of digital environments and tools? Are they improved or just different? What implications arise that are directly related to this ever expanding digital environment?
In exploring this subject, I hope to answer these questions, particularly in the context of primary school education.
My work in education is directly related to the pursuit of these answers. My role sees me working with primary school teachers with vastly different experiences, opinions and abilities with regard to digital practices in the classroom. I hope that by exploring and clarifying my understandings in this field, I will be better equipped to collaboratively navigate the ever-changing landscape that educators face.
With such a wide distribution of knowledge and skills demonstrated by teachers and students alike, the terms ‘digital native’ and ‘digital immigrant’, as coined by Marc Prensky in 2001, are often used to help explain the digital divide. These terms, however, do not sit comfortably with me when the former is often used to refer to the younger generation and the latter connected with the teachers born before this digital revolution. Prensky states that our students today are native speakers of digital language, yet I would also consider myself a native speaker because I have used the language as it has developed. I have lived in the time when the language was invented so I could also be considered a native speaker. The fact that some people choose not, or have no need, to use the language does not necessarily mean that they are immigrants any more than a person who does not use language related to disciplines that use a specific language are eg music, medicine, law. There may be a digital divide, but I don’t believe it has a great deal to do with when one was born. I agree with Gerald Haigh who writes in Open University research explodes myth of 'digital native’ that there’s no evidence of a clear-cut digital divide. Use of technology varies with age, but it does so predictably, over the whole age span. And secondly, although younger people are more likely to be positive about technology, there is evidence that a good attitude to technology, at any age, correlates with good study habits.
![]() |
| creative commons licensed (BY) flickr photo by Mike Sansone: http://flickr.com/photos/mikesansone/2606565992 |
An area of interest I aim to explore further is that of digital literacy. My understanding of digital literacy is the ability to efficiently and effectively select and use a variety of digital technologies to locate, understand, synthesise, evaluate, create and communicate information whilst applying social and ethical protocols in order to protect and respect self, others and property. For teachers who are not digitally literate, supporting the development of these skills in their students will be a significant challenge.
An aspect of the information environment that has been brought to my attention by embarking on this subject is that of digital preservation. On a personal level, I have always understood the need to back up data, especially after losing data that could not be retrieved. I had not, however, considered the impact that this concept has on larger scale. I am comforted to know that the International Internet Preservation Consortium is working on our behalf to ensure that our web is preserved for future generations. On a local level, it makes me wonder about what I should be preserving and encouraging others to preserve. Can we rely on the cloud to keep our data safe? Hopefully access to the cloud will not be dependent on specific hardware (yet I suspect at some time in the future it will) like previous storage solutions were such as floppy discs and, more recently, CDs and USBs. My first instinct is to think that all will be safe in the cloud. That was, at least, until last week when a radio discussion I was listening to drew my attention to the disastrous effect a solar storm would have on our society if one such as the Carrington event of 1859 were to happen today. Dr Karl explained how an event such as this would impact on our everyday lives, from banking and GPS navigation systems to the watch we may be wearing on our wrist.
| St Francis - Kindy |
![]() |
| Poem - Handwriting test - Year 6 |
I look at the work samples above from my days in primary school and wonder what future generations will have to show of their past or, indeed, what they will consider valuable.
References:
Haigh, G. (2011). Open University research explodes myth of 'digital native'. Merlin John Online.
Prensky, M. (2001). Digital Natives Digital Immigrants. On the Horizon 9(5). Retrieved http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/Prensky%20-%20Digital%20Natives,%20Digital%20Immigrants%20-%20Part1.pdf
Monday, January 12, 2015
ICT changes things
It seems that the variety of ICTs appearing in schools is growing at a rate many find difficult to keep up with. Where once teachers only had to worry about what to do with a few desktop computers, we now face the challenge of deciding which of the latest technologies on offer we can/should harness in the classroom for enhancing or, indeed, improving educational outcomes for our students. Having decided that we must have the latest, dare I say, gadget in our classroom, what is the process we go through to convince the school community that this is a good idea?
Supposedly we have experimented with the new technology and have seen the educational potential of adding it to our toolkit, but the next step is not always easy, especially when funds are always short. One problem we face is the requirement from various stakeholders to demonstrate how the new technology will improve learning. This in itself is problematic given the speed with which new technologies are appearing and the difficulties with conducting long term research when the ‘goal posts’ keep changing.
Bigum (2012) describes a loop that schools can find themselves in:
- New ICT appears in the market
- Arguments are put forward as to how this new technology will improve current teaching and learning practices. These arguments are usually made in terms of how the technology will address a particular problem.
- The case for the technology is successful and it is introduced into the school.
Before too long, a new technology enters the market and the loop begins again. To justify the expenditure, calls are made to explain or prove how learning is being improved. Bigum states that this search for improvement is a distraction and can cause people to miss the obvious - ICT changes things. Interesting things happen with ICT that are unexpected and bear little resemblance to what what anticipated.
The problem with this loop is that the technology is usually made to fit in with current practices - it would be difficult to successfully make a case for introducing the technology by saying, “let’s just see what happens, how it changes things.” I have attended many parent meetings in primary schools where the parents insist on knowing how the technology will improve learning - it is their main concern. It is therefore necessary to focus, not on improvements that, at this stage, cannot be quantified, but on how ICT has changed the way we do things. When we accept this, we may move towards exploring how school can change to accommodate a more contemporary approach to learning.
Reference:
Bigum, C. (2012). Schools and Computers: Tales of a Digital Romance. Transformative Approaches to New Technologies and Student Diversity in Futures Oriented Classrooms. L. Rowan and C. Bigum, Springer Netherlands: 15-28.
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Affordance Analysis
In his article, Affordance analysis - matching learning tasks with learning technologies, Bower (2008) presents a design methodology for matching learning tasks with learning technologies. The use of the term affordance was previously unfamiliar to me but Bower has assisted me in understanding how consideration of affordances relating to technology as well as educational goals will greatly enhance the use of ICT in classrooms to meet the varied learning needs of students.
As with all use of technology in school, the first priority is to establish intended learning goals and the possible ways to achieve them. Once established, the affordance requirements of the task/s can be determined. The teacher must decide what it is the students will need to be able to do throughout the task e.g read, write, listen, watch, link, modify and many other affordances (some of which are represented on the figure below).
Whilst determining the affordances of the task, the teacher may begin to consider the elearning tools available that may suit the learning intention and the affordances of that technology.
Although unfamiliar with the term affordances, I have considered affordances of technology when planning for its use in class. It is often what leads to the selection of device for a particular task or component of a task. For example, if students need to capture still or video image, an iPad would be an appropriate device. If students are required to share their work and provide feedback, this could be done using blogging software on either tablet or laptop. However, if students are required to comment directly into a document, this may best be achieved using Google docs on a laptop.
Employing a methodology that focuses on affordance of both task and technology should focus the teacher more on ensuring that the learning task fulfills the pre-identified cognitive requirements and the chosen technologies, in turn, support that cognition. This will, hopefully, ensure rich tasks that can be used as exemplars for others in the learning community. Bower also suggests building a portfolio of approaches for identifying, describing, analysing and allocating technologies for deployment. Affordance analysis provides a means to do this and highlights the critical aspects of the selection process - the cognitive and technological requirements.
Bower, M. (2008). Affordance analysis—matching learning tasks with learning technologies. Educational Media International, 45, 1, 3–15. Retrieved http://www0.sun.ac.za/ctl/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/bowerarticle.pdf
Friday, December 5, 2014
Digital native vs digital immigrant
![]() |
| by Campus Party Brasil |
The terms ‘digital native’ and ‘digital immigrant’, as coined by Marc Prensky in 2001, do not sit comfortably with me. I have heard many speakers and teachers use the terms, usually as a basis for promoting the use of technology in classrooms. Whilst I do not argue that the children of today have only known a world with technology and are often comfortable in using a variety of technologies, I do not believe that those of us born before the digital revolution are any less capable of operating within this developing environment.
Prensky states that our students today are native speakers of digital language, yet I would also consider myself a native speaker because I have used the language as it has developed. I have lived in the time when the language was invented so I could also be considered a native speaker. The fact that some people choose not, or have no need, to use the language does not necessarily mean that they are immigrants any more than a person who does not use language related to disciplines that use a specific language are eg music, medicine, law.
![]() |
| by Aron Stevenson |
Prensky refers to people as having digital immigrant accents and states that schools often feel as though they are staffed by heavily accented foreigners.
![]() |
| by Mario & Amanda |
Another aspect of the digital divide that is often commented on is the ability of digital natives to multi-task. Can students really learn whilst watching TV or listening to music? Wood et al in their article, Examining the impact of off-task multi-tasking with technology on real-time classroom learning, concluded that while multi-tasking did not seem to affect rote memorization, it might hamper higher-order tasks that involve understanding material and application of the material to novel situations. The results of studies are consistent with both the cognitive bottleneck theory of multi-tasking and provide evidence that attention, especially for complex tasks, can be impaired when multi-tasking is involved.
There may be a digital divide, but I don’t believe it has a great deal to do with when one was born. I agree with
Gerald Haigh who writes in Open University research explodes myth of 'digital native’ that
there’s no evidence of a clear-cut digital divide. Use of technology varies with age, but it does so predictably, over the whole age span. And secondly, although younger people are more likely to be positive about technology, there is evidence that a good attitude to technology, at any age, correlates with good study habits.
Friday, November 21, 2014
Technology vs Pedagogy
![]() |
| by Wesley Fryer |
We have been talking about technology as if it is something brand new for the past decade. Since the introduction of the iPad into classrooms and the availability of more affordable technology such as Chromebooks , the conversation seems to have increased, especially with the move towards BYOD in many schools.
We have been saying for years that is is not about the tools, it is about the learning. And yet, we still talk about the technology. I believe this is because many teachers are trying to work out how to incorporate technology into the programs they may have been using for years; the technology is still a substitution for books, pencils, paper.
So, if we focus on technology, we do miss the central issue - pedagogy. When teachers adopt a more contemporary approach to learning, the technology required to support this will eventually move into the background - students will reach for the readily available technology that will fulfill their needs, whether that be to investigate, collaborate, create or communicate their ideas (and in ideal situations, all four).
Paul Saettler (as cited in Roblyer & Doering, 2014) said "Computer information systems are not just objective recording devices. They also reflect concepts, hopes, beliefs, attitudes." We may ask if the current technologies being used in classrooms do, in fact, reflect our hopes, beliefs and attitudes with regard to educational outcomes for students? The move towards personalisation of learning requires a broader approach to the use of ICT than was possible in the past. We have seen the use of technology develop from being used predominantly for consumption to an emphasis being placed on creation. Whilst technology can have an enormous impact on what is possible in education today, unless it is being driven by solid, contemporary pedagogy there is a risk of the technology remaining a shiny gadget which contributes little value to student learning outcomes.
ICT General Capabilities in all Subject Areas will be a key driver in helping teachers to develop an innovative approach to contemporary pedagogy.
Teachers who struggle with technology should consider setting up their own peer network and seek help at the point of need. Use the technology available to learn about the technology - YouTube is now the go-to place for finding out how to do almost anything. A Google search can also provide access to ideas tried and tested by other educators from around the world.Utilising students' skills will also harness their knowledge and build a learning community within the classroom where everyone feels comfortable enough to ask for help (including the teacher).
References:
Australian Broadcasting Corporation (2012). 21st century education. Future Tense. Retrieved from
Roblyer, M., & Doering, A. (2013). Integrating Educational Technology into Teaching: International Edition, 6th Edition, Pearson.
Sunday, August 17, 2014
A Day with George Couros
I gathered with approximately 100 primary school teachers today to learn from George Couros.
Here is my Storify of the day...
Here is my Storify of the day...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







